When Great Shows Go Wrong: K-Dramas that Missed the Mark

Casting is crucial in bringing K-Dramas to life, but sometimes it can backfire spectacularly. Here’s a rundown of the five most criticized casting decisions of 2025 that have left fans shaking their heads.

1. Delusion: A Portrait Gone Awry

Set to premiere in 2026 on Disney+, "Delusion" follows a painter tasked with immortalizing the reclusive Song Jeong Hwa, who hasn't been seen in decades. While many are excited to see Bae Suzy in a leading role, the casting of Kim Seon Ho is raising eyebrows. The actor's past scandal, involving serious allegations from an ex-girlfriend, has fans wondering if his presence will overshadow the narrative. Even with an apology issued and some reconciliation, viewers remain split.

2. A History of the Losers: A Troubling Past

Debuting on February 26, 2025, "A History of the Losers" is based on a popular webtoon and tackles the struggles of dating underdogs. However, the casting of Cho Byeong Kyu and Song Ha Yoon has stirred controversy as both faced accusations of school violence. This shadow has cast a pall over the series even before its launch.

3. My Dearest Nemesis: A Chemistry Crisis?

In "My Dearest Nemesis," the romantic tension hinges on a department store leader, Moon Ga Young, reconnecting with her first love, played by Choi Hyun Wook. Here lies the rub: Choi's age—22 during filming—renders him a decade younger than his character in the webtoon. Though some viewers initially doubted the pairing due to this age gap, early reactions suggest that the on-screen chemistry may prove them wrong.

4. Boyfriend on Demand: BLACKPINK's Jisoo Under Fire

Excitement surrounding Netflix’s "Boyfriend on Demand," starring BLACKPINK’s Jisoo alongside seasoned actor Seo In Guk, quickly turned into skepticism. Described as a romantic comedy about a webtoon producer escaping reality through a virtual dating simulation, many netizens have expressed doubts about Jisoo’s acting chops, especially following her earlier performance in "Newtopia," which faced harsh criticism.

5. Mean Love: A Heartfelt Confusion?

Yet to generate as much buzz as the other titles, "Mean Love" also finds itself in hot water over its casting choices. The details remain scant, but whispers of discontent hint at potential missteps in this anticipated drama.

Final Thoughts: The Gamble of Casting

In the dynamic world of K-Dramas, casting can make or break a series. As 2025 unfolds, it will be fascinating to see whether these contentious choices lead to success or backlash. Fans are eagerly waiting to see if these dramas can overcome the casting controversies that threaten their potential.