Introduction

As Ruben Amorim prepares to lead his beleaguered Manchester United squad into a clash against Liverpool this weekend, he undoubtedly carries the weight of reflection on what could have been. The 39-year-old Portuguese manager, once seen as a prospective candidate for the Liverpool managerial role after Jurgen Klopp's departure, now finds himself grappling with the pressures of failure, having watched his team lose their last four matches.

Current Standings

While Manchester United struggles, Liverpool sits at the pinnacle of the Premier League, firmly in the title race under the guidance of newly appointed manager Arne Slot. The stark contrast between the two clubs raises a compelling question: Would the Reds be soaring if Amorim had been at the helm instead?

Amorim's Journey

Amorim emerged as a front-runner for Liverpool's managerial vacancy, hailed for his commendable track record at Braga and Sporting Lisbon. His innovative tactical style and success with young talents positioned him as an alluring option for the Merseyside outfit. However, despite his impressive credentials, Liverpool opted for Slot after agreeing on compensation with Feyenoord, leaving Amorim to lead a United squad in turmoil.

Tactical Differences

The decisive factor in Liverpool's choice was a fundamental disagreement over tactics. Amorim's penchant for a 3-4-3 formation, though effective in his previous roles, lacked the tactical adaptability Liverpool desired. In contrast, Slot has maintained a modified version of Klopp's previous 4-2-3-1 setup, which has proven to be the right fit for the Reds, seamlessly integrating new players into a system that is yielding results.

Amorim's Approach

As Amorim grapples with the challenges at Old Trafford, his steadfast adherence to his preferred tactical philosophy has emerged as a topic of scrutiny. "Maybe, or you continue with your idea and they have to change the coach," he stated recently, emphasizing his commitment to his approach. Yet, this rigidity raises concerns about whether he can turn United's fortunes around or if it will lead to further complications.

Potential Impact of a Switch

Had Amorim taken charge at Liverpool, significant tactical changes would have been necessary, and key players might not have thrived in his system. For example, Ryan Gravenberch has flourished in his deeper role this season, a position that Amorim's tactics may not have supported. Similarly, star forward Cody Gakpo, who has excelled on the left flank, might have found himself positioned differently under Amorim's strategy.

Current Transfers

Furthermore, Amorim's success may have required considerable investment to acquire players that fit his tactical blueprint, while Slot has made minimal signings, bringing in only Federico Chiesa and Giorgi Mamardashvili so far.

Looking Ahead

As the two managers prepare for their tactical showdown, Amorim will need to craft a plan to counter Slot’s well-balanced lineup. Liverpool's form and confidence make them a daunting opponent, and Amorim's challenge is not merely to achieve a turnaround but to instill faith in a once-mighty team that has struggled to achieve its potential this season.

Conclusion

Will Amorim thrive in this testing environment, or will Liverpool’s dynamic approach further highlight the disparity between the clubs? The weekend clash promises to be a thrilling encounter, offering a glimpse into the future of both managers and their respective teams. Fans will watch closely, aware that in the realm of football, fortune can shift in an instant.