Nation

Heartbreaking Dilemma: Maid Wants to Leave Singapore After Missing Her Child, Employer Feels Unfairly Stuck!

2024-09-24

Introduction

In a recent social media post that has sparked intense discussions online, a Singaporean employer shared her distressing situation after her Indonesian maid requested to return home just 11 months into her employment. The maid's reason? A deep yearning for her child left behind in Indonesia.

Employer's Frustration

The employer, who took to the Facebook group “MDW in Singapore,” expressed frustration over the unexpected request, feeling it put her family in a difficult position. She outlined the considerable effort she put into bringing her helper to Singapore, including navigating complex paperwork and financial arrangements to settle outstanding loans for her maid's placement.

Financial Implications

Highlighting the financial implications, the employer noted that had the maid made this request within the first six months of her employment, she would have been eligible for a no-cost replacement from the agency—a benefit for which she paid extra. Now, with that option off the table, she is faced with the dilemma of how to handle her maid’s departure.

Pressing Questions

In her post, she posed several pressing questions: "If I send her home, what happens to her salary for September that I've already paid? Can the agent or the Ministry of Manpower (MOM) offer any compensation since she is leaving before the contract ends?"

Netizens' Responses

Responses from netizens highlighted the inherent risks of hiring domestic helpers in Singapore. Many pointed out that hiring maids is akin to a gamble; there's always a possibility of losing them unexpectedly without any compensation, underscoring that the employer bears the full brunt of repatriation costs once the contract is broken.

Advice for the Employer

Some commentators advised the employer to engage in open and empathetic conversations with her helper to find a possible compromise. Suggestions ranged from negotiating a few more months of service to addressing any underlying concerns the maid may have regarding her work conditions.

Ministry of Manpower Guidelines

The Ministry of Manpower has guidelines stating that if a maid chooses to leave early, she must typically serve a notice period agreed upon with her employer or provide compensation in lieu. However, in cases of urgent family matters or financial constraints, flexibility may be required. Employers are encouraged to be compassionate, which might involve waiving certain terms to ease the transition.

Logistical Challenges

In Singapore, the process of terminating a maid's contract and arranging for her return home involves various logistical tasks, including covering airfare and transport costs. The employer must cancel the work permit within a week after the maid's last working day, ensuring she leaves within two weeks thereafter.

Seeking Quick Replacements

For those needing a swift replacement, the MOM advises utilizing the Advance Placement Scheme, which connects employers with a pool of helpers already residing in Singapore, thus mitigating lengthy wait times often associated with overseas recruitment.

Conclusion

This emotional saga sheds light on the complexities of employing foreign domestic workers and the emotional toll it can take on both parties involved. How employers navigate these situations speaks volumes about their approach to labor and compassion in domestic settings. Stay tuned as we follow this ongoing story!