
Tragic Botched Execution: Inmate Suffers After Firing Squad Fails to Hit Target
2025-05-09
Author: Charlotte
A Disturbing Trend in South Carolina Executions
In a shocking revelation from South Carolina, a death row inmate endured a harrowing execution experience last month when prison officials failed to follow proper procedures during a firing squad execution. Mikal Mahdi, the second inmate to be executed by this method in just five weeks, suffered prolonged pain due to shooters missing their target.
Prolonged Pain and Suffering During Execution
According to autopsy results and evidence analyzed by Mahdi's legal team, the execution did not adhere to protocol, resulting in a death that exceeded the expected 10 to 15 seconds of consciousness. This disturbing find was reported following intense scrutiny of photographs and documents obtained by The Guardian.
A Grim Procedure and Heartbreaking Final Moments
Mahdi, who received his death sentence back in 2006, was executed on April 11. Witnesses reported that he had a target placed over his chest, designed for the three executioners to aim at from approximately 15 feet away, while witnesses observed from behind bulletproof glass. In his final moments, Mahdi was hooded, and after taking a few deep breaths, the shots were fired.
Tragically, he cried out upon impact, his body visibly contorting as the bullets struck, and he appeared to suffer despite being declared dead less than four minutes after the shots rang out.
Resurgence of Firing Squad Executions Amid Controversy
Mahdi's execution marks the second firing squad death in South Carolina within a month, following Brad Sigmon's execution on March 7—the first in the U.S. in 15 years. Notably, South Carolina law permits inmates to choose their execution method, with concerns over the lethal injection process driving some to opt for firing squad.
Facing a Grim Choice: The Options Provided to Inmates
Both Mahdi and Sigmon were faced with the unsettling choice of execution methods, including lethal injection and the electric chair. Mahdi's lawyer, David Weiss, condemned the method as a horrifying act unworthy of a civilized society, denouncing the options as barbaric and inhumane.
Historical Context and Controversial Views
Historically used for military mutinies and as a governmental tool of terror, the re-emergence of firing squads has sparked debate among lawmakers. Some argue it is a quicker and more humane alternative, especially amidst challenges in obtaining lethal injection drugs.
A Call for Reflection on the Inhumanity of Execution Methods
As South Carolina grapples with the ethics of its execution methods, the plight of Mikal Mahdi highlights a disturbing trend in capital punishment, raising profound questions about humanity and justice in a modern society.