Hans Zimmer's Reaction to Academy's Decision

Renowned film composer Hans Zimmer did not hold back when discussing the Academy's decision to disqualify his score for Dune: Part Two from consideration for the Oscars, labeling the ruling as “stupid.” During a recent chat with Josh Horowitz on his podcast Happy Sad Confused, Zimmer elaborated on his thoughts regarding this controversial ruling.

“It’s really not a sore point,” Zimmer remarked. “It’s just such a stupid point — how can it be a sore point?” The two-time Oscar winner explained that he found himself disqualified due to his use of thematic music from the first Dune film in the sequel, which he argued should not be categorized as a traditional sequel. He believes both films are part of a larger narrative arc. “So was I supposed to completely dismantle the character themes and start fresh? That’s just a ridiculous rule. I didn’t want to complain too much about it,” he added.

Academy's Eligibility Rules

This disqualification stems from a review conducted by the Academy late last year, which concluded that Zimmer’s score violated eligibility requirements. Specifically, to qualify, a film’s score must consist of no more than 20% pre-existing themes used in sequels or franchise films. Zimmer was informed that the inclusion of thematic material from the 2021 Dune constituted a violation of this percentage.

Villeneuve's Support

Zimmer's sentiments echo the frustrations expressed by Dune: Part Two director Denis Villeneuve, who vehemently criticized the Academy’s decision, asserting that the two films are “one big movie that is cut in half.” Villeneuve passionately defended Zimmer, stating, “I am absolutely against the decision of the Academy to exclude Hans, frankly, because I feel like his score is one of the best scores of the year. I don’t use the word genius often, but Hans is one.”

Looking Forward: Dune: Messiah and Other Projects

In further developments, Zimmer teased his ongoing collaboration with Villeneuve on Dune: Messiah, the third installment in the Dune universe, revealing, “I talk to Denis every day. Yes, it’s happening sooner rather than later.” When queried about whether he had begun composing the score, he playfully responded, “Mmm, maybe.”

Potential Marvel Projects

Aside from his work on Dune, Zimmer shared insights about potential offers to compose for Marvel films, indicating that he has been approached but has opted to pursue other projects. “I’ve done the trifecta: Batman, Superman, Spider-Man — and Wonder Woman. What more could I do? Maybe some of the lesser-known characters,” Zimmer humorously suggested.

Impact on Awards Season

The disqualification of Zimmer’s score has sparked significant debate within the film industry, raising questions about how rules are applied to creative works that are inherently designed to be interconnected. As Dune: Part Two gears up for its release, fans and critics alike are eager to see how this rule will impact the awards season and the recognition of Zimmer's remarkable contributions to cinema.