
The Shocking Truth Behind Manchester United's Missed Chance to Sign Gianluigi Donnarumma
2025-09-15
Author: John Tan
Why Manchester United Let Donnarumma Slip Away
In a stunning revelation, transfer expert Fabrizio Romano has uncovered the painful reason why Manchester United missed out on signing superstar goalkeeper Gianluigi Donnarumma. Recent clashes with Manchester City have only amplified the regret surrounding this decision.
After making headlines by bolstering their attacking lineup in early summer, United set their sights on a new goalkeeper and central midfielder. However, when their top midfield target, Carlos Baleba, opted to stay put, they shifted their focus entirely to the goalie position.
The Goalkeeping Dilemma
United narrowed their choices down to three potential stoppers: Donnarumma, Senne Lammens, and Emiliano Martinez. Ultimately, they decided against pursuing Donnarumma, ultimately sealing a €21 million deal plus €4 million in add-ons for Lammens on transfer deadline day.
Ironically, Donnarumma also found himself in Manchester, but under Pep Guardiola's banner at Manchester City, for a total cost of €35 million.
A Star in Action
Donnarumma didn't waste time showcasing his skills at City, delivering an impressive performance during their recent derby match. Although Erling Haaland grabbed the player of the match honor with two goals, he was quick to credit Donnarumma’s remarkable display, stating, "Don't forget about Donnarumma! He was unbelievable."
The Missed Opportunity Explained
Romano disclosed that despite initial interest, United never engaged in formal negotiations with Donnarumma’s agents or made an official bid. Interestingly, they believed that while the transfer fee of €30 million plus €5 million in add-ons was manageable, the player's salary demands were non-negotiable due to concerns about Financial Fair Play and their internal salary structure.
Regrets Mount as City Thrives
As the derby unfolded, Donnarumma made a breathtaking save that could have shifted the momentum, while United's new signing Lammens—just 23 years old and with limited experience—didn't even make it to the starting lineup.
This stark contrast in performances shed light on United's decision-making process. While Lammens may develop into a formidable keeper, the immediate reality suggests that if United had been willing to meet Donnarumma’s salary expectations, they would have secured one of the world’s best goalkeepers.
Future Implications for Manchester United
The question now remains: will United learn from this misstep? With ongoing turbulence in the club's managerial landscape and potential player frustrations, the stakes have never been higher.
As fans and insiders alike express shock at the latest developments, the ramifications of this choice could echo through Manchester United's future.