Finance

Shocking Disparity: Local Handyman Charges S$130 While Foreigner Offers the Same Job for S$80!

2025-03-22

Author: Nur

In a surprising revelation that has caught the attention of Singaporeans, a resident recently shared his experience on social media regarding the stark price differences between local and foreign handyman services. This incident stirred up intense discussions among netizens, highlighting a growing concern about service costs and the dynamics of local versus foreign labor.

The resident initially sought a minor handyman fix, expecting the support of local businesses to come with a premium price tag. When he approached a local handyman for the service, he was quoted S$130. However, the response was slow, and he expressed hesitation about the steep price. "Though the rate felt a bit excessive, I considered it," he wrote in his post.

The situation took a turn when he decided to look for alternatives and found a foreign handyman who quoted just S$80. Not only was the foreigner responsive, but he also arrived on time and completed the fix efficiently. Delighted with the service, the resident even tipped the handyman an extra S$10, bringing his total to S$90. This prompted him to question the pricing structures in the handyman service market: "At what point do local prices just not make sense?"

The discussion exploded in the comments, where Singaporeans weighed in on the implications of this price disparity. Some commenters suggested that high local rates might stem from a market where not all customers actively shop around for competitive prices. Others pointed out that perhaps the local handyman's higher charge is reflective of greater experience or a busier schedule, implying that he may already have a consistent flow of work.

Yet, the core issue of entitlement was also raised. A user asserted, "Locals often feel more deserving of higher pay, while foreigners do have the option to return to their home countries if need be." This sentiment sparked further debate about the societal and economic factors influencing local labor markets and wage expectations.

Interestingly, one commenter challenged the original poster's sincerity in wanting to support local businesses. "If cost is your primary concern, are you genuinely aiming to support local, or just seeking the best deal?" he questioned. His perspective emphasized that true support for local enterprises often requires a willingness to pay a little more for quality.

Meanwhile, others defended the local handyman's pricing, claiming that S$130 for a 45-minute job — excluding transport time — is reasonable in one of the world's priciest cities. "If you want quality, you need to align your expectations with the reality of living in Singapore," he advised.

This debate not only raises questions about the local service economy but also reflects broader themes of globalization where the presence of foreign workers adds complexity to labor costs. As the cost of living continues to rise, Singaporeans are reflecting on their spending habits and the values they uphold when it comes to supporting local commerce. What does this mean for the future of local businesses? Only time will tell, but as the discussions continue, one thing is clear: the price you pay can often reflect deeper societal values. Keep your eyes peeled for more surprising insights on this critical issue!