Joy’s Solo Debut: A Mixed Bag for Fans

Red Velvet's Joy has made her solo debut with an original album, and while the musical vibes are positive, the sales figures are alarmingly low. Her album, "From Joy, with Love," is clearly struggling to reach the sales milestones set by her fellow Red Velvet members.

Staggering First-Day Sales Numbers!

On day one, Joy’s album managed to sell just over 38,000 copies, a striking decline from her previously released mini-album, "Hello," which sold 57,000 copies on its first day back in 2021. Fans quickly took notice of this disappointing comparison, especially since this album showcases entirely original tracks for the first time.

How Joy Compares to Fellow Red Velvet Stars

The disparity becomes even more pronounced when stacked against the first-day sales of her Red Velvet peers. Wendy’s album, "Like Water," flew off the shelves with over 68,000 copies sold, while Seulgi’s "28 Reasons" topped the charts with a stunning 134,000. And let’s not forget Irene, who shattered records with her debut mini-album, "Like A Flower," selling an astounding 250,000 copies, the highest among SM Entertainment’s female solo artists.

Mixed Reactions from Fans and Critics

The reaction from fans is a blend of disappointment and optimism. Many expressed their dismay that such a well-crafted album didn’t translate into robust sales, emphasizing its high-quality sound and design. Conversely, others are focusing on the positive aspects, highlighting Joy's impressive chart performance and the affection her new songs are garnering from listeners.

Joy's Comeback Sparks Excitement Despite Sales Challenges

While "From Joy, with Love" may not be flying off the shelves as expected, Joy's comeback is undeniably generating buzz and showcasing her unique artistic qualities. The conversation around her work is very much alive, proving that, despite the numbers, her ability to connect with fans remains strong.