Introduction

In a twist that has left pundits scratching their heads, Erik ten Hag's recent transfer strategy at Manchester United is under scrutiny, with suggestions that he may have an aversion to signing British players. Critics argue that Ten Hag 'hasn't learned anything' from his tumultuous two-year tenure at the club.

Summer Transfer Window Overview

Since taking the reins at Manchester United ahead of the 2022/23 season, Ten Hag has focused heavily on bringing in players he is familiar with from his time managing in the Eredivisie. The Red Devils' summer transfer window was viewed by many as a step in the right direction, with an impressive outlay of around £185 million on new signings. High-profile additions included Joshua Zirkzee, Leny Yor, Matthijs de Ligt, Noussair Mazraoui, and Manuel Ugarte, the latter being a key target as United sought a defensive midfielder to challenge or potentially replace veteran Brazilian Casemiro.

Ugarte's Debut and Performance

However, Ugarte's debut against Tottenham this past Sunday was far from stellar, as the team suffered a 3-0 humiliation at Old Trafford, leading many to speculate about Ten Hag's future. Following this disappointing performance, he has now emerged as the frontrunner for the next Premier League manager to be dismissed.

Criticism of McTominay's Transfer

In an effort to refresh the squad, Manchester United moved several players on, including Scotland international Scott McTominay, who was transferred to Serie A club Napoli for about £25 million with add-ons. This move has drawn criticism, particularly from former Premier League player Paolo Di Canio, who questioned the logic behind selling McTominay for €30 million (£25m) only to spend approximately €50 million (£42m) on Ugarte.

McTominay’s Success at Napoli

Di Canio lashed out, stating, 'How can you sell McTominay to get Ugarte? Ugarte has had great success in Lisbon, but adapting to the Premier League is a different challenge altogether.' His comments reflect a growing sentiment that Ten Hag’s preference for foreign talents over domestic players like McTominay might be a miscalculation.

Current Situation and Future Prospects

After his move to Napoli, McTominay has started well, earning praise for his performance in a recent 2-0 victory over Monza, where he provided an assist. Antonio Conte, Napoli’s manager, praised McTominay's offensive instincts, remarking that he 'has goals in his blood' and possesses significant physicality and technical prowess.

The dynamics at Manchester United continue to raise eyebrows as Ten Hag navigates a difficult season. With rumors swirling regarding his potential dismissal, fans are left to wonder if a change in strategy, particularly regarding player recruitment, could save his tenure at the club. The big question remains: Can Ten Hag right the ship before becoming the next managerial casualty in the Premier League?