SINGAPORE: In a recent post on Reddit’s ‘Ask Singapore’ forum, a man opened up about his career struggles, revealing that he is contemplating a position as a security guard due to the unsatisfactory salary in his current job sector.

He disclosed that entry-level jobs in his field are only offering him between S$2,200 and S$2,600 a month—mostly due to his lack of experience. “I’ve gotten offers as low as S$2,200 because I’m just starting out,” he shared.

The Attraction of Security Roles

On the flip side, he noticed that starting salaries for security roles begin at S$2,600 and can even go up to S$3,000, which immediately makes them more appealing. “There’s also the potential for salary increases based on rank,” he mentioned, highlighting the allure of financial stability.

Reflections on Job Search Challenges

Acknowledging the grueling nature of security work, with long hours and shift schedules, the man reflected on his exhausting job search. After numerous disappointments and low offers, he has become increasingly open to exploring security work as a legitimate option.

Seeking Community Advice

He reached out to the Reddit community, particularly to fellow polytechnic graduates and seasoned security officers, for guidance. “Should I just take this job? I’d love some advice from experienced officers,” he asked.

Mixed Community Responses

However, responses from the community were mixed. While some agreed that security work might be suitable for immediate financial relief, others warned that it could lead to stagnation. One Redditor pointed out, “The security guard job is often a dead end with minimal career advancement. Older workers have spent their lives in these roles but earn very little even after decades.”

Another comment echoed this sentiment: “If you see yourself in this field for the next 30 to 40 years, then go for it, but otherwise, the experience may not translate into other industries.”

Encouragement for Temporary Solutions

Encouragement also emerged from some users advocating patience. They suggested the individual could take on a security job temporarily while continuing to pursue opportunities in his desired field or even furthering his skills.

Alternative Perspectives on Experience

In contrast, others recommended accepting the S$2,200 offer to gain experience, asserting that this could open doors for better-paying positions in the future. One user recounted, “I started at S$2,200 too. It’s my first job, and I took it for the experience. It’s been tough finding something.”

Broader Trends in Singapore’s Job Market

Amidst rising unemployment, many Singaporeans have begun exploring alternative gigs—ranging from delivery riding to freelancing—as they navigate the job market. Some individuals, like an IT support engineer who switched to being a delivery driver, have done so out of necessity or disillusionment with their previous roles.

Advice from Experts