
Asteroid 2024 YR4: Is it Time to Prepare for the Worst and Blow it Up?
2025-09-21
Author: John Tan
The Looming Threat of Asteroid 2024 YR4
Last year, Asteroid 2024 YR4 made headlines when astronomers calculated a potential collision course with Earth by 2032. While they have since dismissed that scenario, there’s still a 4% chance this space giant could collide with the Moon.
Why Should We Worry?
Even low odds can lead to significant consequences. A strike on the Moon could send a vast amount of micrometeoroid debris into low-Earth orbit, posing risks to spacecraft and astronauts aboard the International Space Station.
Planning for Impact: The Science of Prevention
A recent study from NASA and several U.S. institutions presented a range of strategies to tackle this risk. Published in the Journal of the Astronautical Sciences, the research indicates that the most effective option may be to destroy the asteroid before it can reach the Moon.
The Risks of Deflection
Though deflecting the asteroid is usually preferable—ensuring no part of it can reach our celestial bodies—it's fraught with uncertainty. The challenge lies in our limited understanding of the asteroid's properties and the critical precision required for a successful deflection. Miscalculations could potentially redirect it toward Earth instead of away.
NASA’s DART mission successfully altered the trajectory of Dimorphos last year, but projecting the precise force needed to nudge 2024 YR4 involves knowing its density and mass, both of which remain elusive.
The Case for Destruction
Given the uncertainties surrounding deflection, researchers lean towards destruction as a more feasible option. They propose two viable methods for NASA.
The first is a kinetic disruption mission, similar to DART, aimed at breaking the asteroid apart rather than redirecting it. Although this approach has not been tested, there’s a reasonable timeframe for its development, with potential launch windows between 2030 and 2032.
The second option, potentially more dramatic, involves detonating a nuclear device near or on 2024 YR4. Though theoretical, it could effectively shatter the asteroid into smaller, harmless pieces. A suitable launch window for this ambitious mission is projected between late 2029 and late 2031.
What’s Next?
Despite the seven years remaining until the asteroid's closest approach, the scientific community views this as a crucial moment to sharpen our impact prevention techniques. Though 2024 YR4 may pass harmlessly by the Moon, it is a prime opportunity to refine our plans, ensuring we are ready to protect our Earth if the situation demands.