Sport

Yankees Stand Firm on Anthony Volpe as Starting Shortstop Despite Recent Struggles

2025-08-26

Author: Ying

Volpe Takes a Breather

As the Yankees kick off their series against the Nationals, Anthony Volpe finds himself out of the lineup for the second consecutive game. Instead, José Caballero takes the helm at shortstop, giving Volpe a crucial two-day mental reset. Despite this temporary shift, Yankees manager Aaron Boone reassured fans and reporters alike that Volpe remains firmly in the team’s plans.

Boone's Confidence in Volpe

"I view Anthony as our shortstop," Boone stated confidently, dispelling any rumors of a permanent benching. He confirmed that Volpe will return to action tomorrow and is expected to continue in his regular role. Meanwhile, Caballero will serve as the team's versatile utility player.

Volpe's Statistics Raise Concerns

Volpe's performance has been rocky this season, currently boasting a batting line of .208/.274/.400 across 509 plate appearances. While he had a promising start in April, he has struggled significantly since May, hitting just .198/.255/.382 over the last 96 games. His recent slump has intensified—since July 1, he’s batting a dismal .171 with a .203 on-base percentage, making him one of the least productive hitters in the league.

Defensive Woes Amplify Offensive Struggles

Compounding his offensive woes, Volpe's defensive performance has also taken a hit. A Gold Glove winner in 2023, his defensive metrics have declined this season. Currently, he sits around average according to Defensive Runs Saved (DRS) and ranks among the bottom in Statcast’s Outs Above Average metrics. With 17 errors already—tying his career high—only Elly De La Cruz has more errors this season.

Caballero Shining in New Role

On a brighter note, José Caballero, who was acquired from the Rays, has burst onto the scene with an impressive .286 batting average in his first 15 games as a Yankee. Boasting six stolen bases in seven attempts, he currently leads the MLB with 40 steals across both teams this season. While Caballero’s hitting may not be sustainable over the long term—he has a career average of .227—his versatility and speed offer the Yankees a dynamic option in the infield.

Looking Forward

As the Yankees navigate these challenges, the focus remains on Volpe's growth and potential. With Boone's unwavering support and the team's commitment to developing their young stars, there’s hope that Volpe can reclaim his spot among the league's elite shortstops and elevate his game for the remainder of the season.