Key Additions

- WR Deebo Samuel (29): The Commanders orchestrated a trade with the San Francisco 49ers, sending a fifth-round pick to acquire the dynamic receiver. Initially celebrated for their resourcefulness, skepticism soon creeped in. While Samuel once dazzled in 2021 with 77 receptions for 1,405 yards, his recent performance raises concerns. His numbers slid dramatically in 2024, and on-field altercations suggested frustration. Priced at $17.5 million this season, many wonder if the Commanders overpaid for glory days long past.

- LT Laremy Tunsil (30): In a bold but controversial move, the Commanders traded multiple picks to land Tunsil. While he provides an upgrade to the offensive line, his history of penalties and the Texans’ willingness to trade him create doubts. Tunsil’s hefty contract of over $21 million annually adds financial pressure in an already volatile situation.

- iDL Javon Kinlaw (27): The Commanders surprised many by signing Kinlaw for a staggering three-year, $45 million contract. Known for his size, Kinlaw's inability to perform effectively against the run raises concerns, especially after being labeled a liability in crucial games.

- CB Jonathan Jones (31): Entering his tenth season, Jones brings proven experience from the Patriots. However, he is another aging player, which begs the question whether the team is investing enough in youthful talent rather than pursuing veterans past their prime.

Players Retained

The team made some smart decisions by keeping key players: - QB Marcus Mariota (31): As a reliable backup, Mariota brings stability to a crucial position. - TE Zach Ertz (34): After a bounce-back year, Ertz continues to serve as a red zone threat.

However, several retained players have underwhelming past performances, leaving the effectiveness of the roster intact but full of uncertainty.

Departures and Their Impact

The Commanders faced significant losses in the offseason, including: - DT Jonathan Allen, who secured a lucrative deal with the Vikings and has been a defensive cornerstone. - S Jeremy Chinn and OT Cornelius Lucas, who both added depth and experience but are now gone as the team opts for more aggressive veteran signings.

The Big Picture

Despite entering the offseason full of cap space and the opportunity to build a younger, more competitive team, the Commanders appear to have opted for a win-now approach. With 19 players over the age of 30 on the roster, many worry that the strategy lacks foresight. The future of the franchise remains uncertain as the team has limited capital for the next two draft years.

The moves have sparked a heated debate among fans: Have the Commanders gambled their future for short-term gains? With their playoff berth last season representing promise, the current trajectory, teetering heavily on aging talent, risks undermining their hard-earned progress.

Grade: D

As the team navigates these tumultuous waters, Commanders fans must brace themselves for a season filled with potential pitfalls. The reliance on veterans raises serious red flags, and the team may find itself struggling in a highly competitive NFC East. Let's hope the results justify the risk, or it could be a long road ahead for Washington fans looking for consistency and success.