
USMNT September Window: Who's Rising or Falling in the Squad?
2025-09-10
Author: Jia
Pulisic and the 4-3-2-1 Experiment Collapse
In the intense spotlight of the recent September window, the U.S. Men's National Team navigated a tricky landscape. Christian Pulisic and Tyler Adams found themselves in questionable positions, while Sergiño Dest hesitated, leading to defensive chaos against South Korea. The ill-fated 4-3-2-1 formation proved to be a tactical blunder. Though not entirely disastrous, crucial defensive lapses exposed the team's vulnerabilities, making their offensive efforts appear feeble.
A Tactical Shift: Emergence of 3-4-2-1
Recognizing the shortcomings, Coach Pochettino made an immediate pivot. By the hour mark against South Korea, he brought in fresh legs and switched to a 3-4-2-1 formation. This strategic alteration ignited the team's spirit, resulting in a staggering 14-1 shot count in favor of the U.S. The momentum carried into their next match against Japan, where they notched a convincing 2-0 victory—widely regarded as one of Pochettino's finest outings.
Balogun's Breakthrough: A New Star in the Making?
Amidst the fluctuation in performances, Folarin Balogun stood out. Although he squandered several chances, his goal against Japan—highlighted by a powerful stiff-arm to shake off defenders—has solidified his position as the top contender for the No. 9 spot. His combination of tenacity and skill has fans excitedly anticipating his potential.
Defensive Heroes and Doubts
Left-back Arfsten showed marked improvement, particularly after transitioning to a wingback role in the new formation, where he became a standout player against Japan. Pochettino himself praised Arfsten for his character and intelligence on the field.
On the flip side, goalkeeper Freese made crucial saves, yet his ability to control the box remains a concern. If he can refine this aspect of his game, he could become a formidable asset for the team.
Sargent's Struggles: A Stark Comparison
Josh Sargent's ongoing struggles have cast a shadow on his future with the national team. With only five goals in 29 appearances and a prolonged goal drought, his chances of seeing significant playtime in the upcoming cycle seem slim unless he finds success at a bigger club.
Missed Opportunities from Others
Players like Berhalter and Luna left the camp with missed chances to establish their roles. Luna's lack of creativity was especially concerning, while Berhalter's physical limitations were evident in midfield.
Weah's Versatility vs. Performance
Tim Weah's versatility is both a blessing and a curse. Although he’s capable in multiple positions, he has yet to reclaim his dynamic form, casting doubt on his contributions to the squad.
Zendejas Shines at the Right Moment
In a pivotal moment against Japan, Zendejas delivered a crucial goal, suggesting he might play a significant role moving forward. Pochettino remarked on how his performances are putting pressure on roster decisions.
Freeman and Roldan: Solidifying Their Places?
Freeman is emerging as a reliable option, especially if he continues on his upward trajectory. Roldan played a less glamorous role but showed his importance in connecting plays—an asset not to be overlooked.
The Future of CB Depth and Missing Euros
The question of center-back depth remains urgent, with Blackmon’s limitations prompting concerns. Pochettino has hinted at a need to explore integrating players like Walker Zimmerman or Miles Robinson.
Key Players Awaiting Their Chance
Malik Tillman and Weston McKennie are anticipated to return in the next camp, given their critical roles. However, the future of Gio Reyna looms large—widespread speculation surrounds his absence, but a healthy Reyna could significantly elevate the team's attacking potential.
Final Thoughts: Learning from the Past
This recent camp was a blend of trial and error for the U.S., revealing crucial insights as they gear up for the World Cup. While some players have cemented their spots, others face an uphill battle for a ticket to the tournament. As the team evolves, only time will tell who rises to the occasion.