Sport

The Ultimate Grades for Every MLB Team in 2024: Surprises, Disappointments, and What Lies Ahead!

2024-09-24

American League Highlights:
Milwaukee Brewers: A

The Brewers defied expectations by conquering their division for the third time in four years. Remarkably, they faced significant challenges, including the loss of star manager Craig Counsell when he departed for the Cubs, and the pre-season trade of ace Corbin Burnes, hinting at a rebuilding year. However, under new manager Pat Murphy, and despite injury woes to key players, they exhibited resilience, leading to a spectacular season characterized by smart decisions and impressive performances from emerging talents.

Cleveland Guardians: A

Led by rookie sensation Kyle Manzardo, the Guardians demonstrated their competitive edge, with a standout bullpen anchored by Emmanuel Clase. Despite losing ace Shane Bieber early in the season, this team skipped a step back, turning potential adversity into triumph, culminating in an emotional win against the Twins that left their manager teary-eyed and proud.

Kansas City Royals: A-

The Royals are witnessing a dramatic turnaround, with Bobby Witt Jr. arguably crafting the best season in franchise history. Their remarkable recovery from the previous year’s debacle (56-106 record) marks one of the most significant improvements in recent MLB history. With a solid rotation propelled by Seth Lugo’s standout performance, the team’s success is undeniable, even as a late-season slump raises some concerns.

New York Yankees: B+

The Yankees kicked off the season like a freight train but faced issues mid-year with troublesome defense and inconsistent pitching. Aaron Judge and Juan Soto formed an explosive duo, reminiscent of Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig, leading the team while others struggled. They seem set to reclaim their playoff spot after a disappointing previous year.

San Diego Padres: B+

Emerging from a shaky start, the Padres roared back in the second half, yet they were not without their struggles. The addition of dynamic players like Dylan Cease played a pivotal role, while the offensive resurgence led by Manny Machado could position them to be a formidable playoff contender.

Notable Low Performers in the American League:
Los Angeles Angels: F

With continuous injuries and setbacks, including Mike Trout’s early departure and the impending departure of Shohei Ohtani, the Angels have had a disastrous season. This marks the continuation of a disappointing era that has spanned nearly a decade.

Chicago White Sox: F-

The White Sox's abysmal season with an outlook for even further challenges has earned them one of the lowest grades. With no signs of improvement, fans are left in despair over their team's performance.

National League Updates:
Philadelphia Phillies: A-

A triumphant season saw the Phillies capturing the NL East title, but their struggles in the second half now cast uncertainty over their championship aspirations. They’re banking on the power of Bryce Harper and Kyle Schwarber in the playoffs.

Miami Marlins: F

Despite a playoff appearance last year, injuries devastated the Marlins this season. A record number of players cycled through the roster, leading to disarray and a forgettable performance that left fans yearning for stability.

Cincinnati Reds: D+

Hopes were high at the beginning of the season with new additions, but sadly, the Reds stumbled as injuries plagued the roster. They may need a fresh start to reclaim their place in competitive baseball.

Conclusion: A Sports Landscape to Watch

With playoffs looming, how teams perform in the postseason will be pivotal for shaping their trajectories for the next season. Surprises abound in both leagues, and as we gear up for October, there are plenty of narratives that will unfold on the diamond. Which teams will rise to the occasion under pressure? The excitement is just beginning! Stay tuned as we follow each team’s path in the postseason, where anything can happen!