Sport

The Knicks' Stunning Playoff Collapse: A Tale of Despair

2025-05-22

Author: Ken Lee

A Game Like No Other

NEW YORK — Picture a loss so staggering that it leaves its mark on New York City, a place known for its resilience and bustling energy. Knicks fans have experienced a lot, but nothing like this.

After Game 1 of the Eastern Conference finals, the somber atmosphere was palpable as fans shuffled out of Madison Square Garden, their expressions a mixture of disbelief and shock. The only sound echoing through the garden was the squelch of wet shoes against the steps, as if the life had been drained from the crowd.

A Comfortable Lead Turns to Horror

The Knicks held a commanding 14-point lead with just 2:51 left in regulation. Fans began to leave, confident of victory after Jalen Brunson hit a critical three-pointer. But as time ticked away, unease settled in. Just when it seemed the game was sealed, Brunson’s layup pushed the lead to nine with 58 seconds left. Surely, New York couldn’t blow it now.

The Unthinkable Happens

In a shocking turnaround, the Indiana Pacers capitalized on an improbable series of events. Aaron Nesmith hit a record-breaking six three-pointers in the fourth quarter, including three in the final minute alone. Suddenly, the Knicks found themselves scrambling.

Tyrese Haliburton, the Pacers’ rising star, hit a miraculous shot to tie the game, wrestling fate with the basketball gods. It was a two-pointer after his foot barely brushed the line. Overtime beckoned.

Historic Collapse

As the teams moved to overtime, history was already taking note. According to Elias Sports, no NBA team had won a playoff game after trailing by nine or more points in the final minute since 1998—until now.

The Knicks, once powerful and dominant, succumbed to Indiana, losing 138-135. Their late-game consistency had evaporated into thin air, and they found themselves on the wrong side of history.

Post-Game Reflections

Players were left to reflect on missed opportunities. "We played 46 good minutes, but that’s where we lost it," said Knicks center Karl-Anthony Towns. "Execution and discipline are key for 48 minutes."

This season, the Knicks prided themselves on executing clutch plays, snatching victory from the jaws of defeat against teams like the Detroit Pistons and the Boston Celtics. Yet, in this game, it was the Pacers who took advantage of a Knicks team that fell short.

Lessons Learned

There’s a silver lining, though. The Knicks initially played excellent basketball. Brunson dominated with 43 points, while Towns added 35. For most of the game, they controlled the tempo and the boards.

But when it mattered, the Knicks lost their focus. They failed to maintain defensive intensity, allowing Indiana to capitalize on critical mistakes.

A Historical Echo?

Haliburton’s tying shot was eerily reminiscent of Pacers legend Reggie Miller’s iconic moment against Spike Lee in the 1994 playoffs. Just as then, the echoes of history reverberated through the arena.

As the Knicks prepare for Game 2, uncertainty looms. Could this collapse mark the turning point of their playoff journey, or will they rise above it? Only time will tell.

Looking Ahead

"It’s not a good feeling, but there’s still plenty of basketball left to play," Brunson remarked. The Knicks will need to regroup quickly if they hope to reclaim control of their fate in this series.