Unmasking the Mystery of Musical Comedy

Great musical comedies are often elusive gems. They must keep audiences guessing, skillfully weaving unexpected twists that engage and entertain. Enter ‘Smash,’ a dazzling new production that opened Thursday at the Imperial Theater, proving to be the surprise hit we didn’t see coming!

From Screen to Stage: A Bold Transformation

Originally a promising NBC series in 2012, ‘Smash’ had its moments—particularly the intense competition for the role of Marilyn Monroe in a Broadway musical. However, as the drama escalated, it became bloated and lost its spark. Fast forward to its Broadway debut, where the creators have reimagined the show as a lively comedy, leaving us skeptical yet hopeful.

Expect the Unexpected in This Fresh Take

What initially appeared to be a misstep—a rearrangement of the fan-favorite duet ‘Let Me Be Your Star’ into a solo—ultimately showcased the brilliance of the creative team led by director Susan Stroman. ‘Smash’ is more than just a musical; it’s a clever mystery that hooks you from the start, revealing deeper layers as it unfolds.

Star Power and Ambition Collide

In this updated storyline, Ivy Lynn, played by Robyn Hurder, is already shining as a star, while her understudy, Karen Cartwright (Caroline Bowman), dreams of making her mark. As Ivy delves into Method acting, her quest for depth brings chaos rather than clarity, ultimately threatening the production of ‘Bombshell’—the Monroe musical at the heart of ‘Smash.’

A Comedy That Keeps the Plot Moving

With a book by Bob Martin and Rick Elice, ‘Smash’ brings sharp wit and vibrant characterization to the table. The hilarious dynamics among the creative team—especially the affably quirky married songwriting duo—add layers of humor and heart. As things escalate, one of the central questions hanging in the air is: Who will take the stage come opening night?

Dynamic Performances and Stellar Production

The production shines under Stroman's direction, which seamlessly blends humor into the fabric of the show. The choreography, designed by Joshua Bergasse, captivates the audience, while set and lighting designs create a vibrant stage that keeps the pace lively. The music, crafted by Marc Shaiman and Scott Wittman, recalls the classic tunes of the Monroe era and is accompanied by stellar vocal performances.

Revolutionizing the Original Vision

‘Smash’ reclaims and revitalizes the spirit of the original series, cleverly distancing itself from the elements that dampened its success. The absence of the original creator’s credit is telling; for fans, this might feel like a bold pivot, yet for many, it’s a celebration of the musical comedy genre that is both entertaining and refreshing.

The Takeaway: A Reason to Celebrate

In a landscape riddled with forgettable musicals or drab comedies, ‘Smash’ stands tall as a testament to the uplifting power of musical theater. The real mystery lies in how a seemingly chaotic transformation could yield a masterpiece of entertainment that delights and surprises. Prepare for a night of revelry at the Imperial Theater—this isn’t just a show; it’s an experience you won’t want to miss.

‘Smash’ is currently playing at the Imperial Theater in Manhattan. Running time: 2 hours and 30 minutes.