Black Monday, the day when NFL teams typically reshuffle their coaching staff after the regular season, unfolded with a surprisingly calm atmosphere this year. Contrary to expectations of widespread firings, only a handful of coaches found themselves on the chopping block.

Fired Coaches and Retained Leadership

The only head coach to lose his job on the notorious Black Monday was Doug Pederson of the Jacksonville Jaguars, who ended his three-year tenure with a record of 22-29. Meanwhile, the New England Patriots took the unanticipated step of firing head coach Jerod Mayo immediately after his team triumphed over the Buffalo Bills. This result seems paradoxical, as Mayo had only recently shown some semblance of success.

Winners: Head-Coaching Candidates on the Rise

For head coaches looking for a new opportunity, the New York Jets appear to be a hotspot. They have shown interest in a lengthy list of candidates—including Mike Vrabel, Ron Rivera, and even coaching veterans like Rex Ryan and Matt Nagy. The sheer volume of interviews indicates that the Jets are serious about finding the right fit as they aim to reverse their fortunes.

Losers: Indianapolis Colts Fans

Fans in Indianapolis were holding out hope for significant changes, especially after the team posted a disappointing 8-9 record this season. However, general manager Chris Ballard, whose performance has drawn criticism over the years, was confirmed to stay by owner Jim Irsay. The Colts have only won one playoff game under Ballard since his appointment in 2017, a stark contrast to their division rivals, who have fared significantly better in recent years.

Winners: Giants' Brian Daboll and Joe Schoen

The New York Giants took an unexpected turn by retaining both head coach Brian Daboll and general manager Joe Schoen, despite the franchise’s disappointing 3-14 record. Owner John Mara's decision to maintain stability in an otherwise chaotic situation suggests a long-term plan is in place. However, the Giants must now focus on improving their roster and reversing the downturn, particularly after star running back Saquon Barkley left to join a rival team.

Losers: New York Giants Fanbase

While the front office celebrates their retained positions, Giants fans are left disillusioned, yearning for sweeping reforms to turn the franchise's fortunes around. Icons like Tiki Barber have cautioned against fixating solely on the quarterback situation, suggesting that any young QB inserted into the current system would struggle to succeed.

Surprising Winners: Alabama Football

In an unexpected twist, Alabama's football program might also be celebrating following the dismissal of Seattle Seahawks offensive coordinator Ryan Grubb. After a year characterized by lackluster offensive performance, Grubb's potential return to college football could mean he reunites with Kalen DeBoer at Alabama, where they once tasted success together.

Losers: Jacksonville Jaguars Fans

In the wake of Doug Pederson’s exit, Jaguars fans might also feel disheartened that general manager Trent Baalke is staying put. Baalke’s tenure has yielded marginal success, and keeping him could deter top coaching candidates who prefer to work in sync with their GM. The future looks uncertain, and many fans hoped for a more thorough overhaul.

Winners: Mike McCarthy

Dallas Cowboys coach Mike McCarthy continues to dodge the axe despite a mediocre 7-10 season. Desire for a new direction in Dallas has maneuvered McCarthy into a position of potential opportunity, particularly as the Chicago Bears have shown interest in interviewing him for their vacant head coach position.

Disappointing Drama: Black Monday’s Anticipation

The day many waited for was met with notable underwhelming decisions, which left fans and analysts alike expecting more drama and upheaval. Historically known for significant changes and shocking announcements, this year’s Black Monday was notably tame, prompting reflections on the state of the franchises involved.

As teams look ahead and begin to strategize for next season, coaching changes promise to shape the narrative of the 2024 season. The road to redemption has begun for some, while others will continue searching for answers.