Overview of the Controversy

In a recent episode of the "Locked on Big 12" podcast, host Drake Toll stirred the pot by playfully excluding Utah from the power rankings, suggesting that the Utes chose to depart the list after their defeat to BYU. "We had 15 teams, one of them left, and I think we should add another to get back to 16," he quipped, leaving fans buzzing over Athletic Director Mark Harlan's brazen remarks post-game.

Mark Harlan's Post-Game Comments

The backlash stems largely from Harlan's emotional post-game comments, where he vented his frustrations regarding the Big 12 officiating, asserting, “We were excited about being in the Big 12, but tonight I am not.” His rant during an impromptu press conference in the early hours after the game quickly went viral and drew sharp criticism from across the conference.

Harlan went so far as to claim that the game was "stolen" from the Utes, leading to a reprimand from Big 12 commissioner Brett Yormark and a hefty $40,000 fine. In a statement later issued, Harlan acknowledged that his reactions were inappropriate and expressed his commitment to being a constructive member of the Big 12, while also sending goodwill to BYU.

Reactions and Fallout

The fallout from Harlan’s outburst has been significant, with social media lighting up with calls for Utah to be expelled from the conference. Critics have labeled Utah fans as "sore losers" following the tumultuous showdown with BYU, especially after accusations surfaced of a water bottle being thrown at the BYU cheer coach, causing her to be injured. One user on social media echoed the sentiments of many, demanding, "Get them out of the Big 12."

Toll, however, defended the majority of Utah’s fanbase, stating that while negative behavior is typical when emotions run high post-game, it does not define the entire community. He pointed out that his experiences with Utah fans over the weekend revealed that most are nothing short of welcoming and respectful, contrasting the behavior of a few aggressive individuals.

Utah's Transition to the Big 12

The Utes officially announced their move to the Big 12 in August 2023 amidst a significant reshuffle in college football that saw several powerhouse programs changing conferences. They fully transitioned to their new home in the Big 12 on August 2, 2024, amidst high expectations regarding their performance. However, contrary to predictions of dominance, Utah has struggled in their debut season, leading to increased scrutiny and harsher critiques from rival fans and analysts alike.

Looking Ahead

As the dust settles from this recent bout of controversy, it remains to be seen how Harlan's comments will continue to affect Utah’s standing in the Big 12, and whether the Utes can turn around their fortunes on the field in the remainder of the season.