
Knicks' Playoff Hopes Hang by a Thread After Defensive Meltdown in Game 4
2025-05-28
Author: Yan
Defensive Woes Plague the Knicks
INDIANAPOLIS – It was an all-too-familiar scene for Knicks fans as their team faltered in Game 4 against the Pacers. What was supposed to be a firestorm of defense turned into a defensive disaster, evoking memories of the Mike D'Antoni era rather than Tom Thibodeau's disciplined squad.
The Knicks' defense, which had been their pride throughout the season, crumbled under the pressure. Tyrese Haliburton and his teammates unleashed a relentless offensive barrage, leading the Pacers to a decisive 130-121 victory and pushing them within one game of the NBA Finals.
Turnovers and Defensive Lapses
Mistakes became the Knicks' downfall, with a staggering 17 turnovers—five committed by Josh Hart alone. This lack of ball control and defensive discipline allowed the Pacers to exploit every weakness, resulting in 50 points in the paint and 22 in transition.
Despite commendable performances from Jalen Brunson and Karl-Anthony Towns, who racked up a combined 55 points, their defensive liabilities were glaring. While OG Anunoby tried to help, it simply wasn't enough.
Late-Game Struggles
Trailing by 15 early in the fourth quarter, the Knicks attempted a late rally, cutting the deficit down to six on multiple occasions. However, the critical element for a comeback—getting stops—was absent. With just 46 seconds left, Obi Toppin, a former Knick, sealed their fate with a three-pointer that punctuated a lackluster defensive effort.
Facing Elimination in Game 5
Now, the Knicks face the daunting task of winning three straight games against a Pacers team that has barely lost throughout the postseason. The upcoming Game 5 at Madison Square Garden marks their first elimination game of the playoffs, and the team will need to shake off its 3-5 playoff record to avoid an early exit.
A Rollercoaster of Emotions
In a game where the Knicks allowed more points in the first quarter (43) than they did in the entire second half of their previous game (42), it was clear that something was fundamentally broken. Haliburton dazzled with 15 points and six assists in just the first quarter, as the Pacers shot a blistering 15-of-22 from the field.
While Brunson kept the team afloat with 13 first-quarter points and Towns found rhythm in the second, too many turnovers—nine in the first half—gave Indiana opportunities to fast break and score.
The Clock is Ticking
With Game 5 looming, the Knicks need a complete turnaround. Fans are hoping to see a return of that tight, relentless defense and fewer mistakes to keep their playoff dreams alive. Can this team rise to the occasion, or will their season come to a disappointing conclusion? Only time will tell.