Introduction

The 1999 BMW M Roadster has caught the attention of car enthusiasts, with the seller proclaiming it a 'genuine beauty' and lamenting that BMW 'no longer builds automobiles like this.' At a price tag of $21,500, the question remains: does this classic roadster live up to its price?

Pricing Context

For some context, last week’s 1995 Jeep Grand Cherokee Limited sold for $10,500 and received a solid 53% approval rating in the Nice Price or No Dice feature. In contrast, this M Roadster comes at more than double that price while boasting almost 100,000 additional miles on the odometer. It's clear we need to evaluate this vehicle on its individual merits.

The BMW Z3 Series

The BMW Z3 series is often referred to as the 'Cinderella car' of the brand, heavily borrowing its components from the E36 and even the classic E30 3 Series. The M Roadster is no exception, featuring a robust drivetrain and suspension sourced from the iconic E36 M3. Interestingly, the convertible and hardtop designs were crafted by ASC, connecting it to other notable vehicles such as the ACS/McLaren Mustang.

Specifications and Condition

This specific M Roadster is painted in striking Imola Red and features black leather upholstery, complete with a factory optional hardtop that is showcased in the ad. While the convertible top isn't displayed, the owner asserts it’s in 'pristine condition'—a crucial detail for potential buyers.

Under the hood, we find a powerful S52 3.2-liter straight-six engine that churns out 255 horsepower, complemented by a five-speed manual transmission. The vehicle boasts a limited-slip differential and semi-trailing arm independent rear suspension, all crucial for delivering that exhilarating driving experience BMW is known for. Fresh Michelin Pilot tires wrap around the original deep-dish Style 40 alloy wheels, while M3-derived disc brakes ensure stopping power.

The seller claims all mechanical components are in excellent shape, having been serviced by a BMW dealer with new fluids and a fresh clutch. Complete service records and a recent inspection report offer peace of mind for any potential purchaser.

Visual Appearance

Visually, the M Roadster appears to be well-maintained, with flawless paint and uncurbed wheels. However, there are minor adjustments needed for the clamshell hood and the headlamp lenses, which show signs of age but are not major concerns.

Interior Features

Inside, the cabin is nearly spotless, with no wear evident on the seats or the dashboard. It includes the original AM/FM/cassette stereo with a CD changer, embodying the nostalgia of the late '90s.

Mileage and Market Position

The seller humorously claims the car has been driven about 6,000 miles per year on average, but math shows it could likely be around 160,000 miles by now—a significant figure for a performance vehicle. Despite this, they assert it’s a 'turn-key' car ready for enjoyment. They proudly emphasize it was 'built in Germany, NOT in China,' a remark that might raise eyebrows but points to a more classic era of BMW manufacturing.

With a clean title from Arizona, the asking price of $21,500 positions it in a competitive market—potentially outclassing models like the 987 Boxster S or the Nismo 370Z.

Conclusion

So, what do you think? Does the mileage diminish the allure of this M Roadster or is it a reasonable ask for a piece of BMW heritage? Weigh in with your thoughts on this eye-catching sports car!