Summary of Gamer Feedback

In a recent online discussion, gamers have been sharing their thoughts and ratings on the new title, Mario & Luigi: Brothership. With opinions ranging from praise to disappointment, here's a summary of what players are saying.

Positive Reviews

One user, mariomaster96, who is only 14 hours into the game, expressed enthusiasm, stating, "I haven't beaten it yet, but I'm really enjoying it. It’s a huge step up from Paper Jam." They also dismissed complaints about hand-holding and performance issues, suggesting that many players may not have progressed far enough to experience these problems.

Conversely, IceClimbersMain described the game as "a good time" with a rating of 6. They noted some stuttering and frame drops, which they attributed to the limitations of the Nintendo Switch, while lamenting the changes made to Luigi's controls.

As players delve deeper into the game, varying opinions emerge. RenanKJ found the reunion of Mario and Luigi on the first island to be adorable and fun, while sanderev rated it between 8.5 and 9, still loving the game well into their playthrough.

Critiques and Concerns

However, not all feedback is positive. Users like TKundNobody rated it a 7, citing dissatisfaction with the current learning system for pair moves and progression. RubyCarbuncle and mwatcher also echoed concerns regarding Luigi’s control changes, feeling that these alterations detracted from the experience.

The game's soundtrack became a topic of contention as well, with players like SlowPokemon lamenting the absence of composer Yoko Shimomura, leading to a more generic feel, while others described the writing and dialogues as "dry" and lacking the charm of previous titles.

Overall Experience

Despite mixed ratings, several users shared their enjoyment of both the battle mechanics and the vibrant 3D art style. Players like PikminMarioKirby were pleasantly surprised by the challenging puzzles, while Arawn93 rated it a solid 9, glad to see another entry in the series.

Unfortunately, technical issues were frequently mentioned, such as long load times and inconsistent world exploration. Many gamers agreed that, while the overall experience was enjoyable, the game's performance and design elements could have used additional polish, particularly given its price point.

Conclusion

As the community continues to engage, it’s clear that Mario & Luigi: Brothership has sparked a range of emotions, from nostalgia and joy to critiques and disappointment. As gamers provide their ratings—ranging from 4 out of 10 to perfect scores—the consensus hints at a beloved series that may need a bit of refinement but still holds value for a significant portion of its fan base.

So, what score would you give this latest installment in the Mario & Luigi series?