‘Dune: Part Two’ Fights for Oscar Recognition as Submission Sparks Controversy

The team behind "Dune: Part Two" is undeterred in their quest for Oscar nominations, particularly for the extraordinary score composed by Hans Zimmer. Despite some challenges regarding eligibility, Warner Bros. has officially submitted this score for Academy consideration, firmly believing in its artistic merit.

In early October, an independent review raised concerns about whether Zimmer's score adhered to the Academy's eligibility guidelines, specifically since it incorporates thematic elements from his previous work on the 2021 film, "Dune." The Academy has a strict rule stating that sequels and franchise scores can use a maximum of 20% of pre-existing themes. This raised questions about whether Zimmer's composition crossed this threshold. However, insiders reveal that Warner Bros. is optimistic about the score's chances and has made the necessary submissions to ensure it is considered.

The Academy has not yet had the opportunity to review Zimmer's submission, and whether it will appear on the Oscar ballot remains uncertain until the shortlist is revealed on December 17. Warner Bros. recently updated its "For Your Consideration" page to include Zimmer's score, signaling their commitment to pursuing accolades.

Both Zimmer and director Denis Villeneuve have expressed their passionate perspectives on the score's significance. Villeneuve argued, "I don’t think this is over yet… ‘Part Two’ is a new score." This echoes issues he faced in the past when his film “Arrival” had its score disqualified for similar reasons. He emphasizes the artistic depth and beauty of Zimmer’s latest creation, which he believes deserves recognition.

Interestingly, Villeneuve suggests that "Dune: Part Two" should not merely be viewed as a sequel but rather as a continuation of the story. "The story starts the second we finish the first movie,” Zimmer adds, stressing the importance of thematic continuity in the narrative.

Despite the uncertainty surrounding the Academy's decision, Zimmer remains a formidable contender in this awards season, with multiple nominations potentially coming his way — including his work on the highly anticipated World War II drama "Blitz," directed by Steve McQueen.

With a career that spans over four decades and includes 12 Oscar nominations, Zimmer is one of the most renowned composers in modern cinema. His accolades include wins for "The Lion King" (1994) and "Dune." Furthermore, he has garnered four Grammy Awards, six Emmy nominations, and even a Tony nod, showcasing his versatility and influence within the industry.

"Dune: Part Two," which continues the epic saga of Paul Atreides — portrayed by Timothée Chalamet — promises a breathtaking cinematic experience as it delves deeper into a world filled with intrigue, betrayal, and formidable alliances. The film boasts a stellar cast, including Zendaya, Rebecca Ferguson, Austin Butler, and Christopher Walken, and is currently available for streaming on Max.

Stay tuned as the Oscar season unfolds; the fate of Zimmer's score awaits its moment of truth amidst the fervor of Hollywood's awards circuit!