The 2025 college football season kicked off with Texas proudly holding the No. 1 ranking and quarterback Arch Manning widely regarded as the frontrunner for the 2026 NFL Draft. However, after a dismal performance against Ohio State, those expectations are now in jeopardy.

Manning's game was marred by inconsistency, completing just 17 of 30 passes for a mere 170 yards, along with one touchdown and one interception. The Longhorns fell to the Buckeyes, losing 14-7, despite Manning's late effort where he finally connected on a few big throws.

Ohio State’s defensive strategy, orchestrated by former Detroit Lions head coach Matt Patricia, effectively stymied Manning throughout the matchup. Time and time again, even when he had time to throw and open receivers, his accuracy proved elusive. While Manning managed to scramble for 38 rushing yards, he also faced a pivotal moment of failure, getting denied on a crucial fourth-and-goal from the one-yard line.

This loss raises significant questions about Manning's future as an elite quarterback prospect. Critics are beginning to wonder if he has been overhyped due to his illustrious family lineage, including grandfather Archie Manning and uncles Peyton and Eli Manning. Archie himself hinted before the season that his grandson might not be ready for the NFL by 2026, and after this showing, those doubts seem increasingly justified.

Despite the defeat, Ohio State is the reigning national champion and could very well prove to be the top team in this year’s college football landscape. It's possible that Manning simply faced an insurmountable challenge in his season opener and might rebound as the season progresses. However, for now, the spotlight shines uncomfortably bright on the young quarterback, whose performance fell far short of living up to his prestigious last name.