Sport

2025 MLB Playoff Predictions: Who to Buy or Sell Now

2025-09-11

Author: Kai

The Race for October: Who's In and Who's Out?

As the MLB regular season hurtles toward its conclusion, the postseason picture is coming into focus. Currently, the playoff lineup features heavyweights like Boston, Detroit, and Houston fighting for their seats at the October table, while teams like Cleveland and Kansas City cling to hopes of a memorable comeback.

Cleveland Guardians: A Flicker of Hope?

The Guardians are trying to claw their way into contention, sitting 2.5 games back with odds of just 11.1% to make the postseason. They've recently secured 10 wins in their last 14 games, which has ignited a glimmer of hope among fans. But with tough matchups ahead, including a critical six-game series against the Tigers, the odds are against them. **Selling Guardians at +600.**

Kansas City Royals: Stuck in a Rut

The Royals are 4 games back, with playoff chances plummeting to 2.8%. Despite having moments of promise earlier in the season, their recent losses have left them with a mountain to climb. Without a reliable offense, it's hard to envision a sweep that brings them back into the mix. **Selling Royals at +1600.**

Texas Rangers: The Odds Are in Their Favor

Sitting just 1.5 games off the playoff pace, the Rangers boast a robust 48.6% chance according to Baseball-Reference. With a strong performance recently, they have potential for a strong finish. It's wise to invest here. **Buying Rangers at +320.**

Arizona Diamondbacks: Dreaming of a Comeback?

Currently trailing by 4.5 games and facing slim odds (3.1%), Arizona's chances look bleak after a tough stretch. Their final series against formidable teams makes an October miracle nearly impossible. **Selling Diamondbacks at +3000.**

Chicago Cubs: A Solid Playoff Contender?

The Cubs have solidified their spot, needing to navigate the playoffs while facing tough opposition in their division. Despite concerns, they possess the talent to upset higher seeds. **Selling Cubs at +270 to reach NLCS, but Buying at +1600 to win the World Series.**

Boston Red Sox: The Expectations Are High

With a staggering 98.4% chance of reaching the postseason, the Red Sox are in prime position. Their pitching staff and batting lineup have proven formidable, making them one of the favorites. **Buying Red Sox at +320 to reach ALCS and +1900 to win World Series.**

Houston Astros: Can They Regain Form?

Despite a rough patch, the Astros still have a solid chance at playoff contention with a struggling lineup. The team's history in postseason play makes it hard to count them out entirely. However, their current odds feel steep. **Selling all Astros futures at listed odds.**

Los Angeles Dodgers: The Valley of Doubt

The Dodgers find themselves in a precarious situation, underperforming despite having star talent. Investing in their current futures feels risky given their recent struggles. **Selling all Dodgers futures at listed odds.**

Milwaukee Brewers: The Team to Beat?

With the best record in baseball, the Brewers are acing their way into the playoffs. Their exceptional run differential and stable performance make them a strong bet. **Buying Brewers at +750 to win the World Series.**

Philadelphia Phillies: Rising Star or Passing Fad?

The Phillies are in a great position to push deep into the playoffs, especially with an effective roster. However, potential injuries and roadblocks could pose a risk. **Buying Phillies at +100 to reach NLCS while selling other futures.**

Toronto Blue Jays: The Playoff Wildcard?

With playoff odds over 99%, the Blue Jays seem set for the postseason, but their pitching woes raise concerns. While they could surge, their overall performance suggests caution. **Selling Blue Jays at +125 to reach ALCS.**