
Uncovering Fantasy Gold: 16 Underrated Players for Your 2025 Baseball Draft
2025-03-10
Author: Emily
1. Alex Bregman (3B, BOS)
ADP: 107.5 | Scott's Ranking: 78
2023 Stats: AVG: .260, HR: 26, RBI: 75, R: 79
Bregman faced a challenging 2023 season but is poised for a bounce-back in a new environment with the Boston Red Sox. His compelling ability to hit toward Fenway’s left field wall could lead to increased ballpark advantage. Drafting Bregman later could yield significant value.
2. Bo Bichette (SS, TOR)
ADP: 123.5 | Scott's Ranking: 72
2023 Stats: AVG: .225, HR: 4, RBI: 31, R: 29, SB: 5
Bichette’s disappointing year due to a calf injury led to a substantial drop in his draft position. However, he remains a strong talent known for his offensive prowess. Resilient players like him often bounce back, and at just 27, he might surprise many this season.
3. Justin Steele (SP, CHC)
ADP: 126.0 | Scott's Ranking: 103
2023 Stats: W-L: 5-5, ERA: 3.07, WHIP: 1.10, K: 135
Despite missing early games due to a strained hamstring, Steele posted commendable stats akin to his previous season. As he re-establishes himself as a reliable starter, he is a distinguished pick that could outshine other pitchers with higher draft positions.
4. Ryan Walker (RP, SF)
ADP: 132.5 | Scott's Ranking: 112
2023 Stats: SV: 10, ERA: 1.91, WHIP: 0.85
Walker emerged as a standout reliever last season and is confirmed to start 2025 as the closer. His stellar performance makes him a sneaky late-round option for managers looking for solid bullpen productivity.
5. J.T. Realmuto (C, PHI)
ADP: 155.0 | Scott's Ranking: 113
2023 Stats: AVG: .266, HR: 14, RBI: 47, R: 50
Realmuto’s 2023 stats reflect a strong recovery from injury. His return to form makes him a valuable asset among catchers, potentially providing better utility than many catchers in the mid-rounds.
6. Nico Hoerner (2B, CHC)
ADP: 158.0 | Scott's Ranking: 145
2023 Stats: AVG: .273, SB: 31
Hoerner’s recovery from surgery is a concern, but if he’s ready to play by opening day, he could deliver significant value, especially with impressive base-stealing capabilities.
7. Dansby Swanson (SS, CHC)
ADP: 181.3 | Scott's Ranking: 149
2023 Stats: AVG: .242, HR: 16
Despite underperformance last year due to injury, Swanson regained form towards the season's end, showcasing his potential to exceed expectations this year.
8. Isaac Paredes (3B, HOU)
ADP: 185.3 | Scott's Ranking: 123
2023 Stats: AVG: .238, HR: 19
Paredes demonstrated impressive power in 2023 and stands to capitalize on the Astros' home field advantages that favor pull hitters. Expect him to find extra base hits in Houston.
9. Brandon Lowe (2B, TB)
ADP: 206.8 | Scott's Ranking: 147
2023 Stats: AVG: .244, HR: 21
With injury concerns aside, Lowe’s power might be undervalued, making him a worthwhile gamble in the later rounds.
10. Cedric Mullins (CF, BAL)
ADP: 208.8 | Scott's Ranking: 153
2023 Stats: AVG: .234, SB: 32
Mullins’ impressive second-half performance showcases his potential, and grabbing him outside the top 200 could pay dividends for any team.
11. Carlos Correa (SS, MIN)
ADP: 236.3 | Scott's Ranking: 148
2023 Stats: AVG: .310, HR: 14
Although hampered by injury, Correa's past performance indicates he has the talent to exceed expectations this year, making him an interesting late-round target.
12. Ryan Mountcastle (1B, BAL)
ADP: 240.8 | Scott's Ranking: 191
2023 Stats: AVG: .271, HR: 13
Given the shift in the left field fence at Camden Yards, Mountcastle could return to his powerful home run-hitting ways, making him a prime pick for those seeking upside.
13. Jackson Jobe (P, DET)
ADP: 256.3 | Scott's Ranking: 182
2023 Stats: Minors: W-L: 5-3, ERA: 2.36
Often overshadowed by newer prospects, Jobe is seen as a top talent with the potential to secure a rotation spot. Keep an eye on him during the season.
14. Michael Conforto (RF, LAD)
ADP: 307.3 | Scott's Ranking: 208
2023 Stats: AVG: .237, HR: 20
Conforto’s potential resurgence with the Dodgers could land him as an under-the-radar outfielder worth targeting in the later rounds.
15. Nick Martinez (RP, CIN)
ADP: 330.8 | Scott's Ranking: 239
2023 Stats: W-L: 10-7, ERA: 3.10
Martinez's improvement in control makes him an ideal late-round pick for Fantasy managers looking for reliable pitching depth.
As you gear up for your Fantasy Baseball Draft, remember that a strong team is built with both star players and underrated talents. Keep these names in mind to maximize your draft strategy and dominate your league in 2025!