
Outrage in Manitoba: Minister Apologizes After Dismissive Comments About ASL Interpreter
2025-06-30
Author: Emily
A Controversial Comment Sparks Backlash
In a surprising turn of events, Nahanni Fontaine, Manitoba’s Minister of Accessibility, found herself in hot water after making disparaging remarks about an American Sign Language (ASL) interpreter during a graduation celebration on June 26. The incident, caught on a hot mic, has ignited outrage within the deaf community and beyond.
A Distracting Performance?
While chatting with her press secretary, Ryan Stelter, Fontaine expressed her dissatisfaction with the interpreter's hand movements, stating they were a distraction during her speech. She was quoted saying, "I couldn't see anybody on (the left) side—all I could see was her..." Fontaine's remarks, expressing confusion and frustration, were deemed inappropriate and disrespectful.
The Apology
Following public backlash, Fontaine issued a formal apology on Friday. "I sincerely apologize to the deaf and hard of hearing community, and to all Manitobans for my comments," she said. In her statement, she acknowledged that her remarks failed to represent the full complexity of ASL, which is used by thousands across Manitoba.
Understanding the Importance of ASL
Fontaine asserted in her apology that ASL interpretation is vital at public events, highlighting the need for better awareness and respect for those who rely on sign language. She even reached out personally to the interpreter, Sheryl LaVallee, to express her regret.
Impact of the Incident
Deborah Owczar, a deaf attendee of the event, voiced her discontent regarding the situation, stating that LaVallee was removed from the stage post-speech. She expressed that Fontaine's comments tainted the significance of the certificate she received during the ceremony.
Moving Forward: A Call for Respect
As discussions surrounding accessibility and representation in public spaces continue, this incident reinforces the critical need for inclusivity. Fontaine’s experience serves as a reminder of the importance of thoughtful communication and the respect owed to all forms of expression.