Nation

Mark Carney's Constitutional Quandary: Why He Avoids Approving Pipelines

2025-06-07

Author: Jacob

In a surprising twist, Mark Carney seems less interested in leading Canada and more in managing provincial interests. While the allure of being Prime Minister comes with its charms, including high-profile meetings and prestige, Carney's focus appears to stray from exercising the federal government's full authority over national projects.

The 'One Canadian Economy' Initiative: A Misstep?

At a recent press conference, Carney unveiled his "One Canadian Economy" legislation, which he claims will simplify the approval process for projects he deems in the "national interest." He emphasized the urgent need for advancement, suggesting that it has become overly complicated to build essential infrastructure in Canada. But is this truly simplifying the process, or is it merely another layer of bureaucracy?

What Does 'Nation Building' Really Mean?

As Carney discusses nation-building initiatives, a key concern arises: does he really prioritize Canada’s interests? His remarks about giving provinces a veto over significant infrastructure suggest a hesitance to fully wield the federal power at his disposal.

Confusion Over Pipeline Approval Authority

When pressed about pipeline approvals facing opposition from provinces like B.C. or Quebec, Carney promptly stated that consensus among provinces and Indigenous peoples is a must. He even went so far as to proclaim, "if a province doesn’t want it, it’s impossible." This raises eyebrows, as it seems to misinterpret the federal government’s constitutional authority.

The Legal Landscape: A Misunderstanding of Federal Powers

This assertion contradicts the clear constitutional guidelines. Section 92(10) distinctly grants federal powers over projects that connect provinces or transcend provincial borders. The Parliament holds the authority to approve projects deemed beneficial for the country, regardless of provincial opposition.

The Bottom Line: A Power That Exists but is Unused

In essence, if Ottawa opts to push for a pipeline crossing provincial lines, it retains the constitutional right to approve it, even against provincial resistance. This power is not just theoretical; it is backed by judicial precedents. Carney's reluctance to assert this authority raises critical questions about his commitment to national interests and effective governance.