
Asteroid 2024 YR4: Should We Destroy It to Protect the Moon?
2025-09-22
Author: Sophie
Asteroid 2024 YR4: A Growing Threat?
Asteroid 2024 YR4 made headlines last year with alarming predictions of a 3% chance of colliding with Earth. Luckily, updates indicate that it's now set on a collision course with the moon, boasting a 4% likelihood of impact by December 2032.
Why Should We Care?
Even though there aren't immediate plans for permanent human settlement on the moon, a strike from such a sizable asteroid could unleash chaos. It could generate a debris field so vast that it increases micrometeoroids hitting Earth by up to 1,000 times the normal rate, posing serious risks to satellites and astronauts in our orbit.
Two Paths: Deflect or Destroy
To avert a potential disaster, scientists propose two main strategies: deflection or destruction. Deflecting the asteroid slightly might keep it away from both Earth and the moon. But for that, we desperately need accurate information about its mass—a tricky endeavor given its current distance.
The Weighty Mystery of 2024 YR4
Estimates suggest the asteroid is about 60 meters in diameter, but its weight could range dramatically from 51 million kg to over 711 million kg. This variability means the energy required to alter its trajectory could differ wildly. A miscalculation could even worsen the situation, potentially nudging it toward Earth instead of away.
Urgent Missions Needed
To refine our calculations, a reconnaissance mission could be crucial, but time is of the essence. We have until 2028—a mere three years—to launch a mission that could provide essential data. Repurposing current missions is one option, but it comes with the risk of endangering their original objectives.
The Nuclear Option: A Last Resort?
If deflection proves too uncertain, destruction is an alternative. Options include kinetic impact—hitting the asteroid hard enough to break it into smaller pieces—or a more dramatic nuclear explosion. Calculations suggest that a 1-megaton nuke could effectively disrupt 2024 YR4, a tactic not yet tested in space.
The Road Ahead
As we stand on the brink of potentially safeguarding the moon, the next few years will be critical. Whether we choose to deflect or destroy, preparations must begin now. We may not have Bruce Willis to save the day, but advanced technology and bold decisions can pave the way for our protection.